Loading the Elevenlabs Text to Speech AudioNative Player...
back to all

The Price Transparency Challenge

What Payers Can Do to Help Consumers Make Cost-Effective Decisions

Healthcare in the United States is expensive, and many consumers struggle to understand exactly how much their medical care will cost before they receive a bill. Even though price transparency rules have been introduced to help, most people still have trouble comparing healthcare costs, knowing what they owe, and making informed decisions about their care.

A study published in the Journal of Internal Medicine found that while price transparency policies have improved access to cost information, many consumers don’t use or understand the tools available to them. Payers have an opportunity to bridge this gap by offering better cost-comparison tools, clearer breakdowns of out-of-pocket expenses, and improved financial literacy resources.

By improving how pricing information is shared, payers can help consumers avoid surprise medical bills, make cost-effective healthcare choices, and ultimately improve their overall healthcare experience.

1. Making Cost-Comparison Tools More Consumer-Friendly

One of the biggest hurdles in price transparency is that the tools available to compare healthcare prices are often difficult to use. Many consumers don’t know they exist, and when they do try to use them, they often find confusing price variations, incomplete data, or outdated estimates.

A study in Health Expectations found that many patients don’t understand how healthcare pricing works, which prevents them from using price-comparison tools effectively. When consumers don’t have accurate, real-time cost estimates, they may delay care or choose providers that cost significantly more than necessary.

How Payers Can Help:

  • Offer simple, user-friendly cost estimator tools that allow consumers to compare procedure costs across different providers and locations before making a decision.
  • Ensure real-time pricing updates so consumers see the most accurate cost estimates, including provider fees, hospital charges, and insurance coverage.
  • Use AI-powered assistants or chatbots to guide consumers through the process of finding and understanding price estimates.

If payers make cost-comparison tools easier to use and more widely available, more consumers will take advantage of them to make smarter, more cost-effective choices.

2. Providing Clearer Breakdowns of Out-of-Pocket Costs

Even when consumers have access to pricing information, they often don’t understand what portion of the cost they will actually have to pay. The difference between deductibles, co-pays, co-insurance, and out-of-pocket maximums can be confusing, leading to unexpected bills and financial stress.

A report from Frontiers in Digital Health found that patients who received clear cost breakdowns were more likely to seek necessary care without fear of surprise bills. Without clear information, patients often postpone care or avoid medical visits altogether, which can lead to worse health outcomes and higher long-term costs.

How Payers Can Help:

  • Provide a side-by-side comparison of billed costs and out-of-pocket expenses in a way that is easy to understand.
  • Offer personalized cost estimates that show exactly what a member will owe based on their deductible status, insurance coverage, and remaining benefits.
  • Send proactive notifications through email or text to inform members of estimated costs before they schedule a procedure.

The more transparent and easy to understand cost-sharing information is, the fewer surprises consumers will face when they receive their bills.

3. Improving Financial Literacy for Smarter Healthcare Spending

Many consumers don’t understand why healthcare prices vary, how insurance contracts impact costs, or how to effectively use price-comparison tools. Without basic healthcare financial literacy, even the best transparency initiatives won’t be fully effective.

A study in the Journal of Knowledge Learning and Science Technology found that consumers who receive financial education on healthcare costs are more likely to compare prices, choose cost-effective treatments, and avoid unnecessary expenses. However, many payers don’t currently provide enough educational resources to help consumers become more informed.

How Payers Can Help:

  • Launch educational campaigns explaining why healthcare costs differ and how to shop for the best-value providers.
  • Create short, easy-to-understand explainer videos on insurance basics, deductibles, co-insurance, and in-network vs. out-of-network pricing.
  • Host live Q&A sessions or webinars where members can ask questions and receive direct guidance on how to compare costs.

By making healthcare financial literacy a priority, payers can empower consumers to make more cost-effective choices, leading to lower overall healthcare expenses and better outcomes.

4. Strengthening Price Transparency Through Provider Partnerships

Healthcare payers aren’t the only ones responsible for price transparency. Hospitals, doctors, and pharmacies also play a critical role in ensuring accurate cost estimates are available before a patient receives care. However, many providers still struggle to share real-time pricing information with insurers and patients.

According to research published in Azpharm Journal, healthcare organizations that establish stronger price transparency policies see fewer billing disputes, higher patient satisfaction, and lower administrative costs.

How Payers Can Help:

  • Collaborate with providers to ensure accurate cost data is available to consumers before care is received.
  • Encourage bundled pricing models where patients pay a single, predictable fee for common procedures instead of receiving multiple separate charges.
  • Advocate for stronger price transparency laws that require hospitals and doctors to publicly share pricing in a standardized format.

When payers and providers work together to make pricing clearer and more predictable, patients benefit from fewer surprises and lower costs.

Making Price Transparency Work for Consumers

Despite efforts to improve healthcare price transparency, many consumers still struggle to understand costs and make cost-effective decisions. Payers have the ability to close the gap by providing better digital tools, clearer cost breakdowns, stronger financial education, and better provider collaboration.

By focusing on consumer-friendly pricing tools, personalized cost estimates, and stronger financial literacy programs, payers can help members take control of their healthcare spending, avoid unexpected bills, and get the care they need without financial stress.

Investing in better price transparency initiatives is a win-win: consumers become more informed healthcare shoppers, and payers reduce overall healthcare costs by promoting smarter care choices.

Sources

Partner with BHM Healthcare Solutions

With over 20 years in the industry, BHM Healthcare Solutions is committed to providing consulting and review services that help streamline clinical, financial, and operational processes to improve care delivery and organizational performance.

Make the shift to a more effective utilization review process.

Schedule a consultation