Price transparency noncompliance is no longer a theoretical risk. CMS has intensified audits, increased data quality expectations, and escalated penalties. Understanding the true exposure (financial, reputational, and operational) is essential for leadership teams, compliance officers, and revenue cycle leaders.
What Non-Compliance Looks Like
Some of the most common price transparency rule violations identified by CMS and industry groups involve gaps in required disclosures, formatting errors, and accessibility barriers that prevent patients from fully benefiting from published data.
- Incomplete MRFs: Missing standard charge types (gross charge, discounted cash price, payer‑specific negotiated charges, and de‑identified minimum/maximum negotiated charges).
- Missing or misformatted plan identifiers: Insurers and hospitals must align on payer and plan naming conventions that allow consumers to interpret rates.
- File inaccessibility: Files hidden behind search walls, broken links, or pages not clearly labeled for patients violate accessibility expectations.
- Nonstandard formats: Proprietary or unstructured formats that defeat automated analysis. CMS increasingly expects machine‑actionable, standardized fields.
- Shoppable services gaps: Missing or incomplete consumer‑friendly displays for the required shoppable services list (or compliant price estimator).
How CMS Enforces: What Triggers Penalties
CMS uses a progressive enforcement model that escalates from education to penalties. In practice, navigating price transparency regulations is where small inconsistencies can lead to major consequences.
1. Monitoring and Audits
- CMS reviews hospital websites, machine‑readable files (MRFs), and shoppable services displays.
- Targeted audits often focus on data completeness, accessibility, formatting, and whether patients can readily find and use the data.
2. Warning Notes
- CMS issues a warning notice detailing observed deficiencies. Hospitals typically get a defined period to remediate.
3. Corrective Action Plan (CAP)
- If issues persist, CMS requires a CAP with steps, owners, and timelines. Failure to implement or demonstrate compliance can lead to penalties.
4. Civil Monetary Penalties (CMPs)
- Daily penalties accrue until CMS verifies compliance. CMS publishes penalty notices and amounts on its enforcement page, making noncompliance publicly visible.
Financial Impact Model: What Hospitals Actually Pay
For small hospitals, daily civil monetary penalties scale with bed count. Although smaller facilities may face lower daily rates than large systems, the costs accumulate quickly over weeks and months. Even a modest lapse can snowball into a meaningful financial hit if issues are not identified and corrected promptly.
For medium to large hospitals, the exposure escalates significantly. With daily penalties of up to $5,500, a six‑month lapse can exceed $990,000, and a full year can surpass $2 million if CMS determines that noncompliance was continuous. The longer deficiencies persist, the more pronounced the financial risk becomes.
Direct penalties are only part of the picture. Organizations also face indirect costs that can rival or exceed the fines themselves: technology upgrades, data management and validation efforts, and vendor support to remediate and sustain compliance. There may be payer pushback during contract negotiations, patient leakage driven by negative media coverage, and a substantial diversion of internal time and resources away from strategic initiatives. Together, these factors create a total cost of noncompliance that is both immediate and enduring.
Accuracy and Completeness
CMS signaled tighter expectations via an RFI focused on accuracy and completeness. The thrust: it is not enough to post “a file.” It must be accurate, comprehensive, current, and machine‑readable in a way that enables real‑world comparison.
Industry stakeholders, including hospital associations, have commented on the scope and burden. However, the overall direction points to stronger oversight and standardized reporting elements.
Key Takeaways
- Penalties: CMS can levy civil monetary penalties up to $5,500 per day, depending on hospital bed count and noncompliance duration. For a full year of noncompliance, exposure can reach multi-hundred-thousand-dollar amounts to more than $2 million, depending on hospital size and how CMS calculates the penalty period.
- Recent Enforcement: CMS continues to publish enforcement actions and penalty notices. For example, its public list documents hospitals that received warning notices, corrective action plans (CAPs), and civil monetary penalties, including Arkansas Methodist Medical Center and Community Care Hospital in 2025, with Arkansas Methodist fined $309,738 for 247 days of noncompliance. See the CMS enforcement actions page for current cases and amounts.
- Persistent Gaps: Oversight data show that accuracy and completeness are common failure points: misformatted files, missing required standard charge elements, inaccessible or hard‑to‑use links, and payer‑specific negotiated rate gaps continue to drive findings.
FAQs
What are the penalties for noncompliance with the Price Transparency Act?
Hospitals can be fined up to $5,500 per day for failing to comply with the regulations.How can I ensure my hospital complies with the Price Transparency Act?
Regularly review pricing files, ensure they meet the requirements, and stay updated on CMS guidelines to avoid penalties.What should I do if my hospital receives a penalty notice?
Consult with legal counsel and compliance experts to understand the implications and explore options for appeal or remediation.
Learn more about price transparency regulations & download a free Healthcare Price Transparency Compliance Kit.
Leveraged Expertise You Can Count On
Each week, we email a summary along with links to our newest articles and resources. From time to time, we also send urgent news updates with important, time-sensitive details.
Please fill out the form to subscribe.
Note: We do not share our email subscriber information and you can unsubscribe at any time.
Sources
- Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS)
Hospital Price Transparency Enforcement Actions
https://www.cms.gov/priorities/key-initiatives/hospital-price-transparency/enforcement-actions - Department of Health & Human Services (HHS) Office of Inspector General (OIG)
Not All Selected Hospitals Complied With the Hospital Price Transparency Rule
https://oig.hhs.gov/reports/all/2024/not-all-selected-hospitals-complied-with-the-hospital-price-transparency-rule/
Previous Articles
Partner with BHM Healthcare Solutions
With over 20 years in the industry, BHM Healthcare Solutions is committed to providing consulting and review services that help streamline clinical, financial, and operational processes to improve care delivery and organizational performance.
We bring the expertise, strategy, and capacity that healthcare organizations need to navigate today’s challenges – so they can focus on helping others.
Are you ready to make the shift to a more effective process?